Dawson, pp. 194-195: Fuller, Consideration and Form

41 Colum.L.Rev. 799, 800-801 (1941).

 

Consideration has both a formal and a substantive aspect.  We refuse to enforce promises of gifts or promises without consideration because of the informal manner in which they are made.  Another way to justify non-enforcement of gift promises is that the cost of enforcing such promises exceeds the societal benefit.

 

Formality has three functions:

 

1.     The evidentiary function – formality provides evidence that a contract exists.

2.     The cautionary function – formality forces the parties to slow down and think about what they’re doing.

3.     The channeling function – formality is a simple and cheap test of enforceability.  It is a signal to courts and to laymen that the contract is good and enforceable.  Forms are most useful to parties who want to make agreements that will be enforced by a court.  In other words, if you want to make a legally binding promise either as the promisor or promisee, it’s helpful to use a form or seal.

 

Back to Formality

Back to Casebook Notes